What Makes a Wig Look Fake? (And How to Make it Look More Natural)

Back

Featured here: Diva by Ellen Wille in shade Dark Chocolate Rooted

Education & Learning

What Makes a Wig Look Fake? (And How to Make it Look More Natural)

A well-made wig should look realistic, feel comfortable, and blend seamlessly with the wearer’s overall appearance. However, there are several reasons why a wig may look fake, such as excessive shine, an unnatural hairline, or an improper fit. The good news is that many of these factors can be improved with the right techniques. Choosing high-quality fibers, selecting the right cap construction, and styling the wig properly can help create a more natural-looking wig. In this guide, we’ll explore the most common reasons wigs look fake and share expert tips on how to make a wig look more natural for comfortable, everyday wear.

Reasons Why a Wig Looks Fake

Even high-quality wigs can sometimes appear unnatural if certain details are overlooked. Here are the most common reasons why a wig may look fake:

1. Shiny Synthetic Fibers. Some synthetic wigs may have an unnatural shine as opposed to human hair, which has a more natural luster.

2. Incorrect Color or Texture. If the wig's color or texture doesn't match the wearer's natural hair or appears too uniform, it can make the wig look fake. Real hair often has subtle variations in color and texture. This is often referred to as “Barbie hair,” when the wig looks too perfect or overly uniform.

3. Visible Wig Cap or Wefts. If the wig cap is visible or the wefts are exposed, it can make the wig seem unrealistic.

4. Lack of Movement. Natural hair has movement and body. Low-quality wigs can look stiff and unnatural, lacking the flow and bounce of real hair.

5. Unflattering Style. A wig that doesn’t complement the wearer’s face shape or skin tone may appear less natural. Overly styled hair or outdated cuts can also make a wig look less realistic.

6. Wrong Size or Position. A wig that doesn't fit properly can appear fake, especially if it sits too high on the head or doesn't blend well with the wearer's hairline (as demonstrated in the picture below). An ill-fitting wig can also be uncomfortable to wear.

7. Unnatural Hairline. A poorly constructed or unrealistic hairline can make a wig appear less natural.

8. Poor Maintenance. Poor maintenance and lack of proper care will make a wig look fake. Wigs require proper care and maintenance to look their best. Neglecting the wig can lead to tangling, frizzing, and an overall fake appearance.

9. Lack of Scalp Visibility. In natural hair, the scalp is visible through the strands. However, some wigs have hair that appears too dense and hides the scalp, creating an unnatural appearance.

10. End of Lifespan. Wigs don’t last forever. While some wigs have longer lifespans than others, daily wear will naturally cause them to wear over time. As a wig nears the end of its lifespan, it may begin to look less natural.

Tips on How to Make a Wig Look Natural

To ensure a wig looks natural, it's essential to invest in a high quality wig made from premium synthetic fibers or human hair. Additionally, choosing a wig to suit your features, styling the hair, and maintaining the fibers will contribute to a more realistic appearance. Here are ways to make a wig look natural:

Remove the Shine. If a wig is too shiny or appears artificial, lightly mist the fibers with water or dry shampoo to reduce shine. Also, when the wig’s hair is one-dimensional in color or super straight, it may appear overly lustrous. Try toweling or fluffing up the hair to break up the sheen.

Find the Right Size. Wigs come in various sizes, such as petite, average, and large. It’s important to know the right cap size to ensure a proper fit. Remember: A well-fitting wig helps ensure a natural look. It should sit perfectly along the hairline, and ear tabs should sit in the proper position. Use the adjustable straps to tighten or loosen the fit.

Opt for Lace Front Wigs. Lace front wigs create one of the most natural-looking hairlines available. For wigs without a lace front, styling the hair with bangs or face-framing pieces can help conceal the hairline.

Close up of the lace front on Corey by Envy in shade Honey Breeze

Choose the Right Cap Construction. Wigs are available in several cap constructions, including wefted, monofilament, and hand tied designs. For a more natural appearance, monofilament and hand-tied wigs create the look of hair growing directly from the scalp. Wigs with monofilament tops allow the hair to be parted and styled in multiple directions.

While wefted wigs can also look natural, styling options may be more limited, especially if the wig has a wefted top. If any part of the cap becomes visible, styling techniques and products can help conceal it.

Comb the Wig Throughout the Day. Use a wide tooth comb and gently run it through the wig’s fibers throughout the day. Not only will it prevent tangling and frizzing, but will also prevent the wig from looking like a helmet by the end of the day.

Choose Rooted Colors & Highlights. Select colors that have dimension, like rooted shades or multi-dimensional highlights to help break up the color. If a wig does not have a root, use eyeshadow, brow powder, or Envy’s Love Match to blend into the hair.

Featured here: Julianne by Jon Renau in shade FS17/101S18 Palm Springs Blonde

Choose a Wig That Complements Your Face Shape and Skin Tone. When purchasing a wig, a good place to start is picking a wig that closely resembles your bio hair. However, if you want to venture out, consider your head size, face shape, and skin tone. Choose colors that flatter the face and complement your skin tone.

Still not sure? Book a complimentary virtual consultation with one of our Wig Experts!

Wash the Wig. We recommend washing a wig every 6-8 wears and using specially formulated care products for alternative hair fibers. Regular maintenance will help extend the life of wigs and toppers.

Style the Wig. Some wigs come with a zigzag part, which is designed to add volume during packaging. This part can easily be brushed out for a more natural look. Additionally, if the cap has a monofilament top, change the part. Straighten, curl, or add waves to the hair, if made with heat friendly fiber. Also, don’t forget to accessorize with headbands, ponytail holders, and bows to complete its look!

10. Replace the Wig Regularly. With proper care and maintenance, synthetic wigs may last 3–5 months. Human hair wigs may last approximately 9-–12 months. To extend the life of a synthetic wig, steaming can help smooth frizz and refresh the style. If the fiber is heat friendly, heat tools may also be used to reduce frizz or reshape the style. For human hair wigs, using a deep conditioner can help keep the hair soft, healthy, and manageable.

Pro Tip: If a wig is made with regular synthetic fiber, the Envy 3-in-1 Airstyler can be used to help smooth frizz, refresh waves or curls, and restyle the hair.

Final Thoughts

Achieving a natural-looking wig often comes down to the details. Choosing a well-made wig, ensuring the correct fit, selecting flattering colors and styles, and maintaining it properly can all make a significant difference in how realistic it appears.

With the right techniques—such as reducing shine and styling the hair—a wig can look incredibly natural and feel comfortable for everyday wear. By investing in quality and taking the time to care for it properly, wearers can enjoy a confident look that enhances their personal style.

For more wig tips, please visit our Wigapedia.